Notes for group leaders and mentors
College runs on one question: What is the evidence here, and who believes it? Nothing here needs you to know the answer first. Read with a friend or mentor, and let the questions do the work.
- The reader is an adult. Treat the Together layer as two people reading, not a lesson. Your own doubts are allowed in the conversation.
- Don’t rush to answers. John lets questions hang: Nicodemus asks “How can these things be?” (3:9), and we never hear what he made of the answer. You can let questions hang too. A reader whose questions are taken seriously keeps reading.
- The writing is theirs. Ask only whether there’s a line they want to share.
- “The Jews” in John. John often uses the phrase for the leaders who oppose Jesus, while Jesus, his disciples and nearly everyone in the story are Jewish. The setting is a bitter split between synagogue and church (9:22, 12:42, 16:2). These lines have been used to justify hatred of Jewish people. Say plainly that they don’t.
Passages to know about
| Passage | What it is | Suggestion |
|---|---|---|
| John 7:53–8:11 (session 10) | The woman caught in adultery | Missing from the earliest manuscripts, and placed elsewhere in some others. Read it, read your Bible’s note, and talk about why it was kept. |
| John 8:44 (session 10) | “You are of your father the devil” | See the note on “the Jews” above. Read it as a line from a family fight that later became a weapon. |
| John 14:6 (session 16) | “No one comes to the Father, except through me” | The question that comes up most with friends of other faiths. Talk about what it claims about Jesus, and what it doesn’t settle about who God can reach. |
| John 19 (session 21) | The crucifixion | Marked Read together. |
| Genesis 1–11 (Door 1) | Creation, the flood, and science | The door is built to separate what the text claims from what it doesn’t. Let the reader ask about evolution and the age of the earth; don’t make the door hang on one answer. |
| Genesis 6–9 (Door 1) | God floods the earth | Say that it is troubling. Notice the covenant at the end (9:8–17). |
| Genesis 9:18–29 (Door 1) | Noah curses Canaan | It was used for centuries to defend the enslavement of Africans. Name that misuse directly. |
| 1 Corinthians 5 (Door 2) | A man expelled from the church | Read through to 2 Corinthians 2:5–11, where many read Paul urging the church to forgive and restore an offender. |
| 1 Corinthians 6:9–11 (Door 2) | A list of sins, often translated with words about same-sex relations | Wroot Press reads it this way: nobody knows exactly what the two Greek words mean (arsenokoitai and malakoi, “soft”). Paul had other words for male-male sex and didn’t use them. A list we can’t translate with confidence can’t settle the question. We support full inclusion. Others read the list as a prohibition; say that this is a real disagreement. |
| 1 Corinthians 7 (Door 2) | Marriage and singleness | Paul ranks singleness above marriage for his own time (7:7, 7:26). That surprises most readers; let it. |
| 1 Corinthians 11:2–16; 14:34–35 (Door 2) | Head coverings; women to be silent | Some manuscripts put 14:34–35 after 14:40, and 11:5 assumes women pray and prophesy aloud. Read the two passages together. |
| Revelation (Door 3) | Violence, plagues, beasts | Christians disagree widely about how to read it. Keep the door’s question in front: who claims to rule, and who actually does. |
Sessions to read with a friend or mentor
- Session 21, The cross (John 19). Pilate says “Behold, the man!” (19:5). What do you see?
Every session
| # | Session | Notice | Together |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | The Word John 1:1–18 | John opens with “In the beginning,” the first words of Genesis. Open Genesis 1:1–5 beside it. | “The light shines in the darkness, and the darkness hasn’t overcome it” (1:5). Where do you need that to be true? |
| 2 | Come and see John 1:19–51 | Jesus’ first words in John are a question: “What are you looking for?” (1:38). Nathanael scoffs, and Philip doesn’t argue: “Come and see” (1:46). Start the questions list. | Is “come and see” a good answer to a skeptic? |
| 3 | Wine and the temple John 2 | John puts the temple scene at the start. Mark puts it in the last week (Mark 11:15–18); open both. Start the signs list (2:11). | Why might John move the temple scene to the beginning? Readers disagree about whether it happened once or twice. |
| 4 | Nicodemus John 3 | He comes “by night” (3:2). Watch for him again at 7:50–51 and 19:39. Read 3:16 where it stands, in the middle of the conversation. | Is coming to Jesus by night, with questions and unseen, a good start or a hiding place? |
| 5 | The woman at the well John 4 | It is the longest conversation Jesus has with anyone in John. Her town believes “not because of your speaking” but because they heard him themselves (4:42). The second sign is at 4:54. | Where should God be worshipped? Look at Jesus’ answer (4:21–24). |
| 6 | Witnesses John 5 | Jesus calls his witnesses: John the Baptist, his works, the Father, the Scriptures (5:31–39). | “You search the Scriptures, because you think that in them you have eternal life” (5:39). Can someone study the Bible and miss the point? |
| 7 | Bread and the sea John 6:1–21 | Two signs in one session. It is near Passover (6:4). Jesus withdraws when they try to make him king. | Why would Jesus refuse to be made king by force? |
| 8 | A hard saying John 6:22–71 | “I am the bread of life” (6:35) is the first “I am” with a picture. Peter: “Lord, to whom would we go?” (6:68). | Is Peter’s answer a reason to believe, or a shrug? |
| 9 | Credentials John 7 | “If anyone desires to do his will, he will know about the teaching” (7:17). Jesus puts doing before knowing. Nicodemus speaks up (7:50–51). | The crowd argues about credentials. What credentials do people ask of faith now? |
| 10 | Light and freedom John 8 | Many Bibles bracket 7:53–8:11; the earliest manuscripts don’t have it. The chapter ends with “before Abraham came into existence, I AM” (8:58): add it to the list. | 8:44 is one of the harshest lines in the Gospels. Read the notes before you talk about it. |
| 11 | The man born blind John 9 | The man is questioned four times: by neighbors, Pharisees, his parents, Pharisees again (9:8–34). He gets bolder each time and is thrown out (9:34). | Who turns out to be blind (9:39–41)? |
| 12 | The shepherd John 10 | Two “I am” sayings: the door (10:7, 9) and the good shepherd (10:11). “Believe the works” (10:38). | Jesus says to believe the works even if they don’t believe him. Is that a fair test? |
| 13 | Lazarus John 11 | “Jesus wept” (11:35), though he knows what he will do. This sign leads straight to the plot against him (11:50). Thomas is ready to die with him (11:16). | Martha argues with Jesus and believes him in the same breath. Can both happen at once? |
| 14 | The hour comes John 12 | The book of signs ends: “they didn’t believe in him” (12:37). Many leaders believe but keep quiet for fear (12:42). | “Unless a grain of wheat falls into the earth and dies” (12:24). What has to die for something to grow? |
| 15 | Feet John 13 | John’s supper has no bread and cup; it has foot-washing. Open Mark 14:22–25 beside it. The new commandment is at 13:34. | Why is it hard to let someone serve you? |
| 16 | The way John 14 | Three questions, three answers. “I am the way, the truth, and the life” (14:6) answers Thomas’s “How can we know the way?” | What does 14:6 claim, and what doesn’t it say? Think of friends of other faiths. See the notes. |
| 17 | The vine John 15 | “Remain” comes 12 times in this chapter. “I am the true vine” (15:1) is the last “I am” with a picture. | Jesus warns that the world will hate them (15:18–21). Is it fair to apply that to the disagreements you meet? |
| 18 | The Spirit of truth John 16 | “I still have many things to tell you, but you can’t bear them now” (16:12). In John, truth arrives over time. | 16:2 warns of being put out of the synagogues. See the notes on “the Jews” in John. |
| 19 | The prayer John 17 | He prays for “those also who will believe in me through their word” (17:20). That includes the reader. | “That they may all be one” (17:21). Christians are deeply divided. Does that matter to skeptics, and should it? |
| 20 | Truth on trial John 18 | When Jesus says “I am he,” the arresting party falls back (18:5–6). Peter says “I am not” (18:17, 25). Add both to the list. | Pilate asks the question and walks out. Why do people ask big questions and not stay for the answer? |
| 21 | The cross John 19 | John dates the death to the Preparation Day of the Passover (19:14), the day the lambs were killed. Mark has the supper on Passover itself; open Mark 14:12. An eyewitness “testified” (19:35). Nicodemus returns (19:39). | Pilate says “Behold, the man!” (19:5). What do you see? |
| 22 | Mary and Thomas John 20 | The risen Jesus’ first words are questions: “Why are you weeping? Who are you looking for?” (20:15). Compare 1:38. Then the purpose of the book (20:30–31). | Jesus blesses “those who have not seen and have believed” (20:29). Is Thomas’s demand for evidence a failure of faith, or part of it? |
| 23 | Breakfast on the shore John 21 | Three questions after three denials (18:17, 25, 27). Many scholars think the book first ended at 20:31 and chapter 21 was added; others disagree. | Peter asks about another disciple, and Jesus says “What is that to you? You follow me” (21:22). When do you measure your faith against someone else’s? |